Smokers For Sale earns a commission on qualifying purchases through Amazon Associates and the eBay Partner Network. Affiliate links are marked sponsored. We do not quote prices: check the seller's page for current price and availability.
Before you buy: quick fit checks
Most smoker gifts that go wrong are a fit problem, not a quality problem. Five quiet questions avoid most of them.
- What fuel does their cooker burn? Pellet, charcoal, wood (offset), electric or gas decides which wood, smoke tube or accessory makes sense. Our offset vs pellet vs electric comparison explains the differences.
- How big is the cooking area, and how tall is the lid? Rib racks, pans and big cuts need clearance. See how big of a smoker you need.
- Which thermometer system do they already use? Extra probes and receivers usually work only with the same brand's unit and app.
- What is the exact model? Covers, insulation blankets and replacement parts are model-specific. A photo of the cooker's label settles it.
- Where will a new smoker live? Pellet and electric models need an outdoor outlet; renters and condo owners may have patio rules. Our extension cord and GFCI guide covers the power side.
Show gifts for:
Stocking stuffers
Small, useful things a pitmaster goes through or reaches for every cook. Easy wins when you are not sure what they already own.
For: Offset · Pellet · Has everything
Pink (peach) butcher paper roll
Uncoated, unwaxed pink butcher paper is what many pitmasters wrap brisket and pork shoulder in partway through a long cook. It gets used up, so even someone who owns a roll will be glad of another.
Check first: Look for food-grade, unwaxed paper, and pick a roll wide enough for the cuts they wrap.
For: First smoker · Has everything
Bear claw meat shredders
A pair of claws makes short work of pulled pork and chicken and keeps hands away from hot meat. Small, cheap to ship and useful on any cooker.
Check first: Heat-resistant nylon or stainless steel; check that they are dishwasher safe if that matters to them.
For: First smoker · Pellet · Electric
Stainless steel meat injector
An injector pushes marinade or broth deep into turkey, pork shoulder and brisket. Stainless models with a few needle sizes hold up better than plastic ones.
Check first: Look for interchangeable needles and replacement seals or O-rings.
For: Pellet · Electric · Has everything
A-MAZE-N pellet tube smoker
A perforated tube that smolders pellets for extra smoke. Pellet grill owners use it to add more smoke flavor, and it can add smoke to a gas grill or some electric smokers too.
Check first: It burns pellets, so they need a bag on hand, and it should sit on the grate, never in the firepot or hopper.
Read our guide to smoke tubes and boxes →For: Pellet · Offset · Kamado
Stainless steel rib rack
A rack stands racks of ribs on edge so more fit on one grate. Handy for anyone who cooks for a crowd on a small or medium cooker.
Check first: Measure the grate and the height under the closed lid. On a round kamado, check that the rack fits the circle.
For: First smoker · Offset · Kamado
Heat-resistant BBQ gloves
Gloves get used every cook: moving grates, adjusting coals, lifting a hot water pan. A first-time smoker owner often does not have a proper pair yet.
Check first: Ask what they are for. Insulated, heat-rated gloves suit grates and coals; waterproof coated gloves suit pulling hot, greasy meat.
Read our essential accessories guide →Solid gifts
Books, wood and kit that make a cook easier or a cooker last longer. Good for a main present or a joint gift.
For: Offset · Has everything
Franklin Barbecue: A Meat-Smoking Manifesto
Aaron Franklin and Jordan Mackay's book is about fire, wood, cookers and brisket, written from an offset smoker point of view. A strong pick for a stick-burner owner or someone saving for one.
For: First smoker · Has everything
Meathead: The Science of Great Barbecue and Grilling
Meathead Goldwyn's book explains why things happen on a grill or smoker, along with recipes. It suits a curious beginner and the experienced cook who likes to know the reasons.
For: Offset · Kamado · Pellet · Electric
Smoking wood sampler matched to their cooker
A mix of species such as hickory, oak, cherry and apple lets them try different flavors without buying big bags of each. It is a gift that gets used up, which suits someone who already has plenty of gear.
Check first: Match the form to the cooker: chunks for charcoal and kamado, splits for offsets, chips for most electrics, and pellets only for pellet grills and tubes. Never put chunks or chips in a pellet hopper.
Read our guide to chunks, chips and splits →For: First smoker · Has everything
Large cutting board with a juice groove
A big board with a groove around the edge catches juice when they slice a brisket or a pork shoulder. End-grain boards are kind to knives; edge-grain boards are usually lighter.
Check first: Check that it fits their counter and, if they will wash it in a sink, that it fits the sink. Wood boards are hand-wash only.
For: First smoker · Pellet · Offset
A smoker cover made for their model
A cover keeps rain, pollen and sun off the cooker between cooks. It is a good add-on with a new smoker, and a practical gift for anyone whose cooker lives outside.
Check first: Find the exact model name, or measure width, depth and height including side shelves, chimney and hopper. Covers go on only after the cooker is completely cool.
Read our cover fit guide →Thermometers and temperature control
The upgrade gifts most pitmasters want and many put off buying. Ask a few quiet questions first so the gift works with what they have.
For: First smoker · Has everything
ThermoWorks Thermapen ONE
A fast instant-read thermometer for checking doneness in several spots before food comes off. It works with any cooker and earns its place even when they already own a leave-in probe.
Read our instant-read vs leave-in guide →For: Offset · Kamado · Electric · Has everything
ThermoWorks Signals or Smoke (multi-probe)
Leave-in probes that track meat and pit temperature for the whole cook. Signals has four channels and connects over Wi-Fi and Bluetooth; Smoke has two channels and a separate wireless receiver.
Check first: Range through walls varies. If they already use another brand's app or receiver, extra probes from that brand may suit them better.
Read our wireless range guide →For: Pellet · Kamado · Has everything
MEATER Pro wireless probe
A wire-free probe that goes into the meat and reports to a phone app, so there is no cable to pinch under a lid or gasket. Good for rotisserie, kamado and pellet cooks.
Check first: It relies on a phone and Bluetooth range from the cooker to where they sit. Check how many probes come in the pack.
Read our thermometer guide →For: Kamado · Has everything
Charcoal smoker fan controller
A small blower with a pit probe that opens and closes airflow to hold a set temperature. It suits kamado and bullet smoker owners who want to sleep through an overnight cook.
Check first: It needs an adapter that fits their cooker's bottom vent, and a power source. Confirm the exact cooker model before buying.
Read our controller guide →Big gifts: the smoker itself
For a first smoker or a second one in a different style. These are models we cover elsewhere on the site, so each links to a full review. Read the fit checks above first.
For: First smoker
Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 18-inch
A vertical charcoal smoker with a water pan and two cooking grates. It is a long-running design, and it teaches charcoal fire control without the constant feeding an offset needs.
Check first: It burns charcoal and wood chunks. If they cook for big groups, compare it with the 22-inch.
Read our Smokey Mountain 18 review →For: First smoker · Electric
Masterbuilt 30-inch Digital Electric Smoker
A cabinet electric smoker with a digital panel for time and temperature and a side loader for wood chips. It suits someone who wants low effort and a plug-in cooker.
Check first: It needs a suitable outdoor outlet; extension cords should be rated for the load. Compare the 30 and 40 for capacity.
Read our Masterbuilt 30 review →For: Offset
Oklahoma Joe's Highland Offset Smoker
A steel offset with a side firebox for someone who wants to cook with wood and tend a fire. It suits someone who wants to learn fire management, not just set a dial.
Check first: It is large and heavy, and it needs regular feeding during a cook. Make sure they want a cooker that needs tending.
Read our Highland review →For: First smoker · Pellet
Weber Searwood 600 Pellet Grill
A pellet grill with app control that smokes low and can also grill. It suits a beginner who wants set-and-forget cooks and someone moving up from a gas grill.
Check first: It needs a power outlet and a supply of pellets. Check the cooking area against how many people they feed.
Read our Searwood 600 review →For: Kamado
Kamado Joe Classic Joe (18-inch)
An 18-inch ceramic kamado that holds low temperatures for smoking and runs hot for searing. Kamado Joe sells it in Series I, II and III versions, so compare the series before you buy.
Check first: It is heavy, so it needs a cart or a stand rated for its weight. Check the series and what is included.
Read our Classic II vs III comparison →Gifts to skip
- Boxed tool sets with a dozen pieces. They look generous, but the tongs and spatulas are often flimsy and most pitmasters already own the few tools they use.
- "Universal" covers without dimensions. A cover that is too small will not go on, and one that is far too big flaps and holds water. Measure or buy model-specific.
- The wrong form of fuel. Chunks or chips in a pellet hopper can jam the auger, and a bag of pellets is little use to an offset owner. Match the fuel to the cooker.
- A second thermometer app they did not ask for. If they already use one brand's system, another brand's probes means another app and another set of batteries.
- A surprise smoker with no place to put it. Check space, power and any patio rules first, or give a promise to shop together instead.
Gift receipts and return windows
Ask for a gift receipt, and check the seller's holiday return policy before you buy. Many sellers extend return windows over the holidays, but terms differ by seller and by item, and large items like smokers can carry return shipping or restocking rules. For used or refurbished items on eBay, read the listing's return terms, and see our notes on what to inspect on a used smoker and new vs refurbished.
More gift ideas
Narrower guides for specific people and holiday cooks:
- Giving a Smoker as a Gift: How to Choose for a Beginner
- Holiday Gifts for Someone Who Already Owns a Smoker
- Small Gifts for BBQ Fans That Fit in a Stocking
- Christmas Ham and Prime Rib on a Smoker: Gear and Timing
- Black Friday and Cyber Monday Smoker Shopping: What to Check First
- Smoking a Thanksgiving Turkey: The Gear Checklist
- Best Smokers for Whole Turkeys
- Free Up the Oven: Thanksgiving Sides on a Smoker or Grill
- How Much Fuel to Stock for Fall and Winter
Bottom line
Find out what they cook on before you shop. Consumables and thermometers suit almost anyone; covers, parts and fuel need the exact model and fuel type; and a whole smoker is a great gift only when it fits their space, power and patience.